Login
Public ... RtZ Implementation... Zinc borate testing: what's your go-to detection m......
Question
Views: 15 Answers: 1
New Featured

Zinc borate testing: what's your go-to detection method?

Zinc borate is a hazardous chemical and listed in ZDHC MRSL as well as the Wastewater and Sludge Guidelines. What is the best methodology to be employed to detect the contamination of this in formulations and wastewater?

The current Guidelines apply a uniform 500 µg/L reporting limit for boron-based flame retardants and 100 µg/L for zinc borates (CAS 12767-90-7). In practice, most labs assess these via ICP, which only returns total boron and total zinc (when applicable). There’s no substance-specific conversion methodology defined

1. The chemistry isn’t clean. For boric acid (H₃BO₃), elemental B is ~17.5% by mass. So 500 µg/L of “total B” ≈ 2,900 µg/L of boric acid. Or read the other way, a 500 µg/L substance-specific limit on boric acid ≈ 90 µg/L of elemental boron. The same numeric limit lands in two very different chemical realities depending on how you interpret it.

2. Background contamination from groundwater is real. WHO data has boron in groundwater hitting 0.1 mg/L+ in some geologies, and zinc readily leaches from galvanized piping. So a facility that has never used zinc borates can still trigger a "non-conformance" purely from feed water.

Layer onto this the inconsistency for indirect vs. direct dischargers elemental Zn is excluded from the heavy-metal panel for indirect dischargers, but direct dischargers are allowed up to 5 mg/L Zn straight to surface water. That’s hard to defend technically.

Questions for the community:
How are you handling background-corrected interpretation when facilities use well water?

Anyone running paired feed-water + effluent ICP to demonstrate net contribution?

Does anyone have visibility into whether a v2.3 revision is on the roadmap?
Genuinely curious where others have landed on this. 

0
Created: 1 hours ago Modified Last: 1 hours ago , by
J Jakob Müller
Replies
New

If we recall, in ZDHC WWG v2.1, the reporting limits for the five boron-based flame retardants (FRs) and zinc borate were set at 100 ppb. This led to a significant number of failures and potential false positives for these parameters. The topic was subsequently discussed at the Wastewater Council, where one member from the Wastewater Council presented a study indicating that incoming water at certain locations already contained boron at 200–300 ppb. Based on this insight, we analysed historical data, which supported the decision to set the reporting limit for the five boron-based FRs to 500 ppb in the updated version. Accordingly, in ZDHC WWG v2.2, the reporting limit for the five boron-based FRs has been set at 500 ppb, while the reporting limit for zinc borate remained at 100 ppb. Recognising this inconsistency, the Wastewater Council has addressed the issue in the new version of the ZDHC Wastewater and Sludge Guideline (WSG v2) by increasing the reporting limit for zinc borate to 500 ppb, thereby aligning it with the boron-based FRs. The logic applied for determining conformance or non-conformance for Zinc-borate under ZDHC WWG v2.2 is as follows: If zinc > 100 µg/L and boron < 100 µg/L: Conformant If zinc < 100 µg/L and boron > 100 µg/L: Conformant If both zinc and boron > 100 µg/L: Non-conformant The same logic will continue to be applied when ZDHC WSG v2 is implemented from 1 November 2026 onwards; only 100 ppb will be replaced by 500 ppb. However, based on your query, it is not clear what specific change you are proposing. Could you please clarify whether you are suggesting the following? A revision to the reporting limits for the five boron-based FRs? A revision to the reporting limit for zinc borate? A change to the zinc limits for direct discharge? Or proposing to test zinc for the facilities that are an indirect type of discharge?

0

Action Steps

Summarise with Zeddy: ZDHC AI Chatbot
Quickly generate summaries and receive AI insights on reply accuracy and potential enhancements
To use the integrated AI features, you need to sign in.

Related Discussions

Timeline

15.05.2026
1 / 1
15.05.2026